Showing posts with label recruit. Show all posts
Showing posts with label recruit. Show all posts

Friday, January 25, 2013

Rulebook Changes For The NCAA


New changes address the role
of social media in recruiting
The past week brought some big changes for both Division I and Division III NCAA rulebooks.  Last Saturday, January 20, the NCAA Board of Directors passed 25 of 26 proposals to streamline the complex Division I manual.  The goal of the changes, according to NCAA.org, is to adopt “a set of proposals aimed at creating a more flexible manual based on common sense.”  Regarding the changes, NCAA President Mark Emmert was quoted on NCAA.org saying, “These new rules represent noteworthy progress toward what can only be described as more common sense rules that allow schools more discretion in decision-making.”  He went on to say “This vote by the Board of Directors refocuses our attention on the things that really matter, the core values of intercollegiate athletics.”

To see the complete list of new Division I proposals see NCAA.org.  One particular proposal worth noting is 13-3, which will eliminate restrictions on methods and modes of communication during recruiting.  Essentially this change allows coaches to send unlimited text or social media messages to recruits and also make unlimited phone calls during recruiting.  Some high school coaches and student-athlete advocates are concerned about the potentially overwhelming amount of communications top recruits could receive.  However supporters of the proposal believe coaches will learn quickly to exhibit discretion, as student-athletes may be turned off by a barrage of messages.  All of the proposed Division I changes will go into effect on August 1, 2013.  Each change will be reviewed after two years to evaluate effectiveness and whether or not the rule is supporting student-athlete success.

Last Saturday recruiting with social media was also a point of review and discussion for Division III delegates.  Though just barely approved, Proposal No. 9 “allows contact between coaches and prospects as long as it is strictly between only the sender and recipient (for example, no use of public chat rooms, message boards or public communication through a social networking site).”  Direct contact via social media between coaches/recruiters and student-athletes is already permitted in both Division I and Division II.  Supporters for Proposal No. 9 cited benefits the other divisions currently enjoy to help pass the proposal.  They say social media is a more effective way to reach recruits, and many schools allege that student-athletes prefer this type of social interaction to traditional means of communication.  Ref. dallasnews.com, ncaa.org, ncaa.org

Thursday, August 11, 2011

Changes for the NCAA Rule Book

The Division I board of directors announced this week a major change for the NCAA. The board agreed to raise the historical Academic Progress Rate (APR) cutline from 900 to 930. The APR is an NCAA metric that “indicate(s) the success of collegiate athletic teams in moving student athletes towards graduation.” It is calculated based on athletes being academically eligible and for staying with the institution. Adjustments are made when an athlete transfers schools or leaves to pursue a professional athletic career.

This change is one of potentially many changes to come out of a two-day retreat of over 50 university presidents. The retreat was organized by Mark Emmert, NCAA president. Also in attendance were a number of conference commissioners, athletic directors, and select others. In addition to the APR adjustment, the presidential group plans to reevaluate the 434 page NCAA rule book. Currently there are strict guidelines regarding social media and leveraging other forms of technology to communicate between coaches and prospects.

The current rules on social media and recruiting for Divisions I and II include no “comments about possible recruits on an institution’s social media page or a page belonging to someone affiliated with the institution” including photos of recruits. Additionally, communicating via text messaging, Instant Messaging, chat room and message boards (including recruits’ Facebook walls) are not allowed. The rule for Twitter is a little looser, allowing coaches to Tweet as long as they do not reach out to a specific individual. Division III has some slight variations including allowing coaches and schools to advertise their programs on social media pages. However as with Divisions I and II, no individual contact can be made with potential recruits.

Other rules and guidelines will be reconsidered as well, and it is likely that some big changes are on the way. It is expected that regardless of what changes, the penalties for noncompliance (especially as related to severe violations) will be stricter and better enforced. Emmert says he hopes to have the rule book updated by next April. Ref. espn.com, espn.com, ncaa.org, wikipedia.org

Thursday, June 30, 2011

Young Recruits Buying Their Own Hype

ESPN conducted a survey of women’s college basketball coaches and recruiters to uncover what they are really looking for in recruits. WomenTalkSports.com caught my attention by highlighting the below comment from that survey. The comments were all posted anonymously.

One coach or trainer said, “…This generation right now likes to be told what to do. … Four to five years ago there were more kids who understood that accountability piece. It was more about looking for talent because kids were much more disciplined. Technology and media attention have changed kids tremendously. Kids aren't as invested to work in the gym every day. They need to Facebook, and Twitter, and check out what all the media outlets are saying about them. It didn't used to be like that. Kids want instant gratification. And so do their parents. There seems to be no long-term investment into working hard, being accountable and letting natural progression happen."

Upfront, I have never played college basketball, nor have I recruited for it. Perhaps it is true that kids do not like to spend time at the gym. Maybe they do need to be told what to do and act more accountable for their actions. However what, if anything, does that have to do with social media?

Is this recruiter implying that social media has inflated athletes’ egos? That is an interesting statement. Today there are websites completely devoted to high school sports. Maybe the issue is that the best players of today actually know they are the best (where before they could only speculate). Before the internet, local newspapers would cover top talent. However games did not stream on-line, and the stakes (college scholarships-especially for women) were not as high. Years ago the best athletes may not have known they were the best, because it was hard to compare a kid in Maine with one in southern California.

There are two ways to think of this. Perhaps this is just some cranky, old coach who does not ‘get’ social media and likes to look back on athletes of yesteryear through rose-colored glasses. “Back in the day, athletes lifted weights for 6 hours straight, every day…” OR perhaps this is an observant recruiter who is realizing that information overload on an unprepared subject (whether they be student-athletes or, as recent news has taught us, even small time politicians) is a dangerous thing. Maybe there is a little Narcissus in us all, and it rears its ugly head worst in those delicate high school years.

I disagree that technology is making young athletes unaccountable and obsessed with instant gratification. However it is a very real possibility that talented young athletes are buying into their own hype, a hype that has only become possible in a virtual world. Ref. espn.com, womentalksports.com