Showing posts with label rulebook. Show all posts
Showing posts with label rulebook. Show all posts

Thursday, August 8, 2013

How An Optimized Search Got The NCAA In Big Trouble

The NCAA may have search optimized themselves into hot water.  The NCAA has a set of Bylaws that layout what is and is not permissible relating to student-athletes' names and pictures being used to sell merchandise.  One specific Bylaw that address this topic is 12.5.2.2, which states,

“Title:12.5.2.2 - Use of a Student-Athlete's Name or Picture Without Knowledge or Permission.
If a student-athlete's name or picture appears on commercial items (e.g., T-shirts, sweatshirts, serving trays, playing cards, posters) or is used to promote a commercial product sold by an individual or agency without the student-athlete's knowledge or permission, the student-athlete (or the institution acting on behalf of the student-athlete) is required to take steps to stop such an activity in order to retain his or her eligibility for intercollegiate athletics.  Such steps are not required in cases in which a student-athlete's photograph is sold by an individual or agency (e.g., private photographer, news agency) for private use. (Revised: 1/11/97, 5/12/05)”

However institutions have been bending these laws for years by selling merchandise in the likeness of an athlete without acknowledging the athlete's name or actual picture.  Tuesday Jay Bilas publicly outed one of the biggest offenders of breaking this NCAA rule, the NCAA themselves.  Bilas tweeted the below message on August 6 at 11:06am, “Go to ShopNCAAsports.com, type in “Manziel” in upper right search box, hit enter. This comes up. Pic.twitter.com/N7KNvXIu24” The twitpic attached is a screen grab that shows a variety of Texas A&M #2 jerseys for sale.



Over the next few hours Bilas followed the above Tweet with 14 additional Tweets of other examples of names of current and former players names he searched on Shop NCAA Sports and the returned results.  The athletes included Nerlens Noel, Marqise Lee and suspended Notre Dame QB Everett Golson.  However his first Tweet (the above mentioned Tweet) is still perhaps the most surprising and ironic, Johnny Manziel, the Texas A&M quarterback who, according to yahoo.com, “is being investigated for allegedly violating NCAA rules by accepting money in return for autographing his jerseys.”

Bilas’ Tweets garnered attention on Twitter and in the media, and then around 4pm EST yesterday, ShopNCAASports.com removed their search function from their site...or at least hid if from the public.  At the time of this article, it remains removed from the site.  However the NCAA recently did announce that it will not longer sell team-related jerseys.  USA Today quoted NCAA President Mark Emmert saying, ""There's no compelling reason the NCAA should essentially be re-selling paraphernalia from institutions," Emmert said. "I can't speak to why we entered into that enterprise, but it's not something that's appropriate for us, and we're going to exit it.""

This incident raises an interesting question about the site's (and by extension the NCAA's) liability for aligning the keyword phase (in this case a student-athlete’s name) with search results (a jersey of their school and the number they wear).  I inquired with an SEO expert and he explained that the internal search within websites can either be an embedded Google search (meaning the site leverages Google’s search functionality and accepts whatever its crawl technology decides is the best results to display) or the site can use its own, customized search software (likely purchased from a vendor and allows the website owners to set-up those search-return relationships themselves).  Most ecommerce sites employ the latter technique.  That way, they can connect the search terms customers use for given products with the results they think will be most useful (e.g. a search for ‘Father’s Day gifts” is set-up to return ties, golf accessories, etc.).  As ShopNCAASports.com is an ecommerce site, and the way the results displayed, it is very likely the results were manually linked to those student-athlete name keywords.

The site, ShopNCAASports.com, is labeled with the official NCAA logo & links and is copyrighted by Fanatics Retail Group.  The site appears, for all intents and purposes, to be sanctioned by the NCAA.  The questions now are around liability, which casts search & optimization into an interesting light.  Can/should backend code and search software be audited to check if the site deliberately linked a player to a jersey?  Taking that one step further, if the audit comes back that there is a deliberately created link, could the NCAA then be liable for breaking its own rule based on using a player's name without his/her permission, even if it is just on the back end of its site?  If the NCAA is truly breaking its own rules, how can justice be handed down?  Considering the power of the NCAA, one might ask the most important question of all, Quis custodiet ipsos custodes? (Who will guard the guards themselves?) Ref. huffingtonpost.com, usatoday.com, sports.yahoo.com, web1.ncaa.org Pic. Ref. twitter.com

Friday, May 3, 2013

NCAA Football Field Hashtag Rules

The NCAA Football Rules Committee released a bulletin regarding marketing, uniforms and equipment.  After listing a number of exceptions such as school logos, the bulletin stated, "No other advertisements, either by the title sponsor or by any other commercial entity, may be on the field. All other items, including social media designations such as URL’s and hashtags, are prohibited."  This rule is likely in response to hashtags popping up in end zones such as Mississippi State's clever use below.

Mississippi State's End Zone
photo ref. thescore.com
This ruling should not come entirely as a surprise.  The NCAA banned Akron basketball from putting Twitter handles on their jerseys last January.  Even so, the end zone handles were only being used to promote the school, and not for commercial advertising use, and therefore were relatively harmless.  This bulletin also included some other rule specifications including that the pylon logo markings "may not extend more than 3 inches on any side. (Rule 1-2-6)," and "Towels must be solid white and must measure no smaller than 4” X 12” and no larger than 6” X 12.” (Rule 1-4-6-a)."  Interestingly, just 4 months ago, the NCAA announced plans to streamline the complex NCAA rulebook.  At the time, NCAA President Mark Emmert was quoted saying, “These new rules represent noteworthy progress toward what can only be described as more common sense rules that allow schools more discretion in decision-making.”  Apparently they found towel size and pylon logo width to fall outside the 'common sense' capabilities of schools.

Perhaps the most disappointing aspect of the bulletin was that while it did address new jersey regulations, ("New in 2013 Jersey numerals must be of a color that itself is clearly in distinct contrast with the color of the jersey, irrespective of any border around the number. (Rule 1-4-4-c-3)") that rules doesn't seem to prohibit us from having to see more of this next year.

Maryland Uniforms Designed to Look Like the State Flag
photo ref. huffingtonpost.com
Ref. sports.yahoo.com

Friday, January 25, 2013

Rulebook Changes For The NCAA


New changes address the role
of social media in recruiting
The past week brought some big changes for both Division I and Division III NCAA rulebooks.  Last Saturday, January 20, the NCAA Board of Directors passed 25 of 26 proposals to streamline the complex Division I manual.  The goal of the changes, according to NCAA.org, is to adopt “a set of proposals aimed at creating a more flexible manual based on common sense.”  Regarding the changes, NCAA President Mark Emmert was quoted on NCAA.org saying, “These new rules represent noteworthy progress toward what can only be described as more common sense rules that allow schools more discretion in decision-making.”  He went on to say “This vote by the Board of Directors refocuses our attention on the things that really matter, the core values of intercollegiate athletics.”

To see the complete list of new Division I proposals see NCAA.org.  One particular proposal worth noting is 13-3, which will eliminate restrictions on methods and modes of communication during recruiting.  Essentially this change allows coaches to send unlimited text or social media messages to recruits and also make unlimited phone calls during recruiting.  Some high school coaches and student-athlete advocates are concerned about the potentially overwhelming amount of communications top recruits could receive.  However supporters of the proposal believe coaches will learn quickly to exhibit discretion, as student-athletes may be turned off by a barrage of messages.  All of the proposed Division I changes will go into effect on August 1, 2013.  Each change will be reviewed after two years to evaluate effectiveness and whether or not the rule is supporting student-athlete success.

Last Saturday recruiting with social media was also a point of review and discussion for Division III delegates.  Though just barely approved, Proposal No. 9 “allows contact between coaches and prospects as long as it is strictly between only the sender and recipient (for example, no use of public chat rooms, message boards or public communication through a social networking site).”  Direct contact via social media between coaches/recruiters and student-athletes is already permitted in both Division I and Division II.  Supporters for Proposal No. 9 cited benefits the other divisions currently enjoy to help pass the proposal.  They say social media is a more effective way to reach recruits, and many schools allege that student-athletes prefer this type of social interaction to traditional means of communication.  Ref. dallasnews.com, ncaa.org, ncaa.org